Chiropractor or Orthopedic for Lower Back Pain? Expert Comparison Guide

For lower back pain, chiropractors are typically best for recent injuries, disc issues, and mechanical pain using non-invasive spinal adjustments, decompression, and rehabilitation with 70–80% success. Orthopedic doctors are best for severe trauma, progressive neurological symptoms, or failed conservative care requiring surgery. Most cases benefit from chiropractic care first.

Lower back pain has a way of stopping life fast. One day you feel fine. The next, bending, sitting, or sleeping becomes a challenge. When pain hits, many people immediately ask the same question. 

Should I see a chiropractor or an orthopedic doctor for lower back pain?

The confusion is understandable. Both treat back pain. Both order imaging. Both claim results. Yet their approaches, goals, timelines, and costs are very different.

Misconceptions add to the problem. Some believe chiropractors only help mild pain. Others think orthopedics always leads to surgery. Neither is true.

The smartest decision comes from understanding what each provider actually does and when each is appropriate.

With 25+ years of treating lower back pain in Franklin, Cool Springs, and Brentwood, and working closely with orthopedic surgeons, this guide will give you clarity.

In this expert comparison, you will learn:

• The key differences between chiropractors and orthopedic doctors
• When to choose each provider
• Success rates, costs, and recovery timelines
• How collaborative care works
• A clear decision framework for your situation
• Real patient outcomes from both paths
• Answers to the most common questions patients ask

Dr. Crist’s Expert Insight: “I work closely with orthopedic surgeons in Franklin. About 80% of patients who come to me thinking they need surgery avoid it through comprehensive chiropractic care. The ones who do need surgery are in much better shape going into it because we optimize mechanics and strength first. Good outcomes require knowing when conservative care works and when it does not.”

Understanding the Key Differences

Chiropractor vs Orthopedic Doctor: What’s the Difference?

Both chiropractors and orthopedic doctors treat musculoskeletal conditions, but they approach lower back pain from very different angles. The difference is not just training. It is philosophy, tools, and treatment goals.

Understanding these differences helps you choose the right provider at the right time and avoid unnecessary delays, costs, or invasive care.

What Is a Chiropractor?

A chiropractor is a licensed healthcare provider who specializes in neuromuscular and biomechanical disorders, with a primary focus on the spine and its relationship to the nervous system.

Chiropractors are trained to evaluate how spinal joints, discs, muscles, and nerves work together. When motion is restricted or mechanics break down, pain and dysfunction often follow.

Chiropractic Training

Chiropractors complete rigorous doctoral-level education that includes:

• Doctor of Chiropractic (D.C.) degree
  
• Four years of chiropractic graduate education
  
• Thousands of hours studying spinal anatomy, biomechanics, neurology, orthopedics, radiology, and rehabilitation
  
• Extensive hands-on training in manual spinal adjustments
  
• National board examinations and state licensure in all 50 states
  

Chiropractors are trained as primary-contact providers for musculoskeletal pain. They can evaluate patients, diagnose conditions, order imaging such as X-rays or MRI, and create comprehensive treatment plans.

Chiropractors do not prescribe medication or perform surgery. This is intentional, not a limitation.

Primary Focus of Chiropractic Care

Chiropractic care is conservative, non-invasive, and function-driven. The goal is to correct the underlying mechanical cause of pain rather than simply manage symptoms.

Common chiropractic treatments include:

• Spinal adjustments to restore normal joint motion and reduce nerve irritation
  
• Spinal decompression therapy to relieve disc pressure and improve nerve function
  
• Soft tissue therapy to address muscle tension, scar tissue, and fascial restriction
  
• Corrective exercises to improve stability, strength, and movement patterns
  
• Lifestyle and ergonomic guidance to prevent recurrence
  

Rather than masking pain, chiropractic care focuses on restoring normal movement, improving load distribution through the spine, and allowing irritated nerves and tissues to heal.

Core Chiropractic Philosophy

Chiropractic care is based on a simple but powerful principle.

When spinal alignment, joint motion, and neuromuscular balance are restored, the body has a strong capacity to heal itself.

Lower back pain often develops because joints stop moving properly, muscles compensate, and discs and nerves become overloaded. Chiropractic care targets these mechanical failures directly.

This is why chiropractic is often most effective for:

• Mechanical lower back pain
  
• Disc bulges and herniations
  
• Sciatica
  
• SI joint dysfunction
  
• Postural and work-related back pain
  
• Early degenerative changes
  

For the majority of non-traumatic lower back pain cases, this conservative approach delivers excellent outcomes while avoiding medications, injections, and surgery.

What Is an Orthopedic Doctor?

An orthopedic doctor is a medical physician who specializes in diagnosing and treating conditions of the musculoskeletal system. This includes bones, joints, ligaments, muscles, discs, and the nerves that travel through the spine and extremities.

Orthopedic doctors play a critical role in managing complex spinal conditions, severe injuries, and cases where structural damage or neurological compromise is present. They are uniquely trained to evaluate when medical or surgical intervention is necessary.

Orthopedic Training and Education

Orthopedic doctors complete extensive medical and surgical training that includes:

• Medical degree as a Doctor of Medicine (M.D.) or Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine (D.O.)
  
• Five-year orthopedic surgery residency focused on musculoskeletal conditions
  
• Many complete an additional one to two-year spine surgery fellowship
  
• Board certification in orthopedic surgery
  
• Ongoing continuing medical education and surgical skill refinement
  

This training prepares orthopedic doctors to manage both conservative and surgical care, with a strong emphasis on identifying conditions that require advanced medical intervention.

Scope of Practice

Orthopedic doctors are licensed to provide a wide range of medical and surgical treatments, including:

• Prescribing medications such as anti-inflammatories, muscle relaxants, and pain relievers
  
• Ordering and interpreting advanced imaging, including MRI, CT scans, and imaging with contrast
  
• Performing interventional procedures such as epidural steroid injections and facet joint injections
  
• Performing spine surgeries such as discectomy, laminectomy, and spinal fusion
  

Their role becomes essential when back pain is caused by trauma, progressive neurological symptoms, structural instability, or conditions that do not respond to conservative care.

Primary Focus of Orthopedic Care

The orthopedic approach to lower back pain is based on medical diagnosis and risk management.

Treatment typically follows a step-wise progression:

1. Initial evaluation and imaging to identify structural abnormalities or neurological compromise
   
2. Conservative medical management, which may include medications and referral to physical therapy
   
3. Interventional pain procedures when symptoms persist or worsen
   
4. Surgical consultation and intervention when conservative care fails or when serious pathology is present
   

Orthopedic care is particularly valuable for conditions such as fractures, severe spinal stenosis, unstable spondylolisthesis, spinal tumors, infections, and advanced degenerative changes.

Core Orthopedic Philosophy

The guiding philosophy of orthopedic medicine is to progress from the least invasive treatment to more invasive interventions only when medically necessary.

Orthopedic doctors do not recommend surgery lightly. Surgery is typically reserved for situations involving:

• Progressive nerve damage or weakness
  
• Loss of bowel or bladder control
  
• Structural instability of the spine
  
• Severe trauma
  
• Failure of comprehensive conservative treatment over an appropriate time frame
  

When surgery is required, orthopedic care can be life-changing and, in some cases, life-saving.

How Orthopedic Care Fits Into Back Pain Treatment

Orthopedic doctors are not competitors to chiropractors. They are essential partners in comprehensive spine care.

For many patients, orthopedic evaluation provides diagnostic clarity, while chiropractic care addresses mechanical dysfunction and rehabilitation. 

In surgical cases, patients who receive chiropractic care before and after surgery often experience better outcomes due to improved mobility, strength, and movement patterns.

The most successful back pain treatment plans recognize when conservative care is appropriate and when orthopedic intervention is necessary.

Philosophy and Approach Differences

Chiropractors focus on restoring function through hands-on care that improves motion, reduces nerve irritation, and corrects mechanical stress.

Orthopedic doctors focus on medical diagnosis and intervention, with surgery as a solution when structural damage or neurological compromise exists.

Neither is better. They serve different roles and often work best together.

Chiropractor vs Orthopedic Doctor: Quick Comparison

Aspect	Chiropractor	Orthopedic Doctor
Degree	Doctor of Chiropractic	Medical Doctor
Training Length	4 years chiropractic school	Medical school + 5-year residency
Primary Approach	Conservative, functional care	Medical and surgical care
Treatments	Adjustments, decompression, rehab	Medications, injections, surgery
Prescribe Medication	No	Yes
Perform Surgery	No	Yes
Best For	Mechanical pain, disc issues, sciatica	Trauma, neurological loss, surgery
Typical Cost (Franklin, TN)	$1,200–2,400	$3,000–150,000
Success Rate (Non-Surgical)	70–80%	60–70%

Common Causes of Lower Back Pain

Understanding What’s Causing Your Back Pain

The cause of your pain determines the best treatment path.

Causes Where Chiropractic Excels

About 85% of lower back pain cases are mechanical and respond very well to chiropractic care.

Common examples include:

• Herniated or bulging discs
• Facet joint dysfunction
• SI joint dysfunction
• Muscle strain or spasm
• Poor posture and ergonomics
• Mild to moderate degenerative disc disease
• Mild to moderate spinal stenosis
• Sciatica from disc or joint irritation

These conditions respond to spinal adjustments, decompression therapy, and rehabilitation that restore motion and reduce nerve pressure.

Success rates range from 70-80%.

Causes Requiring Orthopedic Care

Some conditions require orthopedic evaluation and possible surgery.

These include:

• Compression fractures
• Severe spinal stenosis with neurological loss
• Cauda equina syndrome
• Severe or unstable spondylolisthesis
• Spinal tumors or infections
• Progressive weakness
• Loss of bowel or bladder control
• Failed comprehensive conservative care

Red Flags Requiring Immediate Medical Attention

Seek urgent orthopedic or emergency care if you experience:

• Loss of bowel or bladder control
• Progressive leg weakness or numbness
• Severe pain after trauma
• Fever with back pain
• Unexplained weight loss
• History of cancer with new back pain
• Inability to stand or walk

“The most important question is not chiropractor or orthopedic. It is what is causing the pain and how severe it is. Most mechanical lower back pain responds beautifully to chiropractic care. When there is progressive weakness, trauma, or failed conservative treatment, orthopedic consultation is necessary.” – Dr. Jason Crist

Not sure which provider is right for you? Get a clear answer tailored to your specific condition.
📞 (615) 771-0022
🌐 Book Online

How Chiropractors Treat Lower Back Pain

The Chiropractic Approach

Chiropractic care addresses the mechanical cause of pain without drugs or surgery.

Spinal Adjustments

• Restore normal joint motion
• Reduce nerve irritation
• Improve spinal mechanics
• Tailored for acute or chronic conditions

Spinal Decompression Therapy

• Computer-controlled traction
• Creates negative pressure in disc space
• Pulls disc material away from nerves
• Highly effective for disc herniations and sciatica

Typical sessions last 15-20 minutes, two to three times per week for six to twelve weeks.

 

Soft Tissue Therapy

• Myofascial release
• Trigger point therapy
• Instrument-assisted techniques
• Reduces muscle tension that perpetuates pain

Corrective Exercises

• Core stabilization
• Hip mobility and strength
• Postural correction
• Proper lifting mechanics

Exercise compliance is the strongest predictor of long-term success.

How Orthopedic Doctors Treat Lower Back Pain

The Orthopedic Approach

Orthopedic care follows a stepped medical model.

Conservative Management

• Anti-inflammatory medications
• Muscle relaxants
• Physical therapy referral
• Activity modification

Interventional Procedures

• Epidural steroid injections
• Facet joint injections
• Radiofrequency ablation

These often provide temporary relief but do not correct mechanical causes.

Surgical Options

• Microdiscectomy
• Laminectomy
• Spinal fusion

Surgery is reserved for cases where conservative care fails or neurological compromise exists.

Comparing Outcomes, Costs, and Timelines

Success Rates by Condition

Condition	Chiropractic	Orthopedic Conservative	Surgery
Herniated Disc	75–85% avoid surgery	50–60%	80–90% initial
Mechanical Pain	70–80%	60–70%	Rare
SI Joint Dysfunction	80–90%	50–60%	60–70%
Degenerative Disc	60–70%	40–50%	70–80%
Muscle Strain	85–90%	70–80%	Not surgical

Chiropractic Timeline

• Weeks 1–2: 30–40% pain reduction
• Weeks 3–6: 50–60% improvement
• Weeks 7–12: 70–80% improvement
• Cost: $1,200–2,400
• Downtime: Minimal

Surgical Timeline Example

• Total recovery: 3–6 months
• Cost: $18,000–35,000
• Complication rate: 10–20%

Decision Framework

Start With Chiropractic If:

• Pain is less than six months old
• Symptoms change with position
• You want to avoid surgery
• No red flag symptoms

See Orthopedic If:

• Severe trauma occurred
• Progressive weakness exists
• Loss of bowel or bladder control
• Conservative care failed

Collaborative Care Works Best

Many patients benefit from both chiropractic and orthopedic care at different stages.

Get an honest evaluation with no pressure.
📞 (615) 771-0022
🌐 Book Online

Real Patient Outcomes

Case 1: Avoided Surgery

A 52-year-old Franklin patient with disc herniation improved 90%with spinal decompression and rehab and canceled scheduled surgery.

Case 2: Surgery When Needed

A 61-year-old Brentwood patient improved with chiropractic care, delayed surgery, then had a successful laminectomy and returned to chiropractic for long-term results.

“The goal is not to avoid orthopedics at all costs. It is to choose the least invasive option that delivers the best outcome.” Dr. Jason Crist

Preventing Future Lower Back Pain

• Core strengthening daily
• Proper lifting mechanics
• Ergonomic workstation setup
• Maintain healthy weight
• Monthly or quarterly spinal checkups

Prevention reduces recurrence from 50%to under 20%.

Choosing between a chiropractor or orthopedic doctor does not have to be confusing. Most lower back pain responds best to comprehensive chiropractic care first. When surgery is truly needed, orthopedic care plays a vital role.

The smartest path is informed, conservative, and collaborative.

Frequently Asked Questions About Chiropractor or Orthopedic for Lower Back Pain

Should I see a chiropractor or orthopedic for lower back pain?

For most lower back pain, start with a chiropractor first.

Chiropractic is best for: 

• Recent injuries (within 6 months) 
• Disc herniations with sciatica 
• Mechanical pain (worse with certain positions) 
• SI joint dysfunction 
• No severe trauma or red flags

Success rate: 70-80% avoid surgery

See orthopedic first if:

• Severe trauma (accident, fall) 
• Progressive leg weakness 
• Red flag symptoms (fever, bowel/bladder changes)

Most insurance covers both. Trying comprehensive chiropractic first (8-12 weeks) is medically recommended before surgery.

Is a chiropractor or orthopedic better for a herniated disc?

Chiropractor is better as a first-line treatment for most herniated discs.

Why chiropractic works: 

• Spinal decompression creates negative pressure, pulling disc material away from nerves
• 75-85% of herniated disc patients avoid surgery 
• Non-invasive with no recovery downtime
• Addresses root cause (mechanics, posture)

When orthopedic is needed: 

• Failed 12 weeks of comprehensive chiropractic care 
• Progressive weakness (foot drop, difficulty walking) 
• Cauda equina syndrome (emergency) 
• Severe, unrelenting pain despite conservative care

Best approach: Try chiropractic first (8-12 weeks). If no significant improvement, orthopedic consultation for possible surgery.

Can a chiropractor diagnose what an orthopedic can?

Both can diagnose musculoskeletal conditions, but scope differs.

Chiropractor diagnostic capabilities: 

• Order and interpret X-rays, MRI, CT scans 
• Perform orthopedic and neurological exams 
• Diagnose disc herniations, stenosis, arthritis, strains 
• Identify when orthopedic referral needed

Orthopedic diagnostic advantages: 

• Order advanced imaging with contrast (gadolinium MRI) • Perform diagnostic injections
• EMG/nerve conduction studies 
• Blood work for infections, tumors

Bottom line: For mechanical lower back pain, chiropractors diagnose accurately. For suspected fractures, infections, tumors, or when surgery likely, orthopedic imaging provides more detail.

What happens if chiropractic does not work?

If you’ve completed 8-12 weeks of comprehensive chiropractic care without 40-50% improvement, orthopedic evaluation is appropriate.

Next steps: 

Advanced imaging (MRI with contrast if needed) 

Orthopedic consultation 

Discuss injection options (epidural steroid injection) • Evaluate surgical candidacy

However, “chiropractic didn’t work” requires clarification: 

Did you receive comprehensive care? (Adjustments + decompression + rehab + lifestyle) 

Did you comply with home exercises? 

Was treatment frequent enough? (3× weekly initially, not 1× weekly)

Many “failed chiropractic” cases received incomplete treatment. Comprehensive care from experienced chiropractor yields 70-80% success.

We track progress objectively. If you’re not improving, we refer appropriately; your outcome is priority.

How long should I try chiropractic first?

Timeline: 8-12 weeks of comprehensive chiropractic care before considering orthopedic consultation.

Week 2-4 evaluation: 

• Should see 30-40% improvement 
• If zero improvement, modify treatment or imaging

Week 6-8 evaluation: 

• Should see 50-60% improvement 
• If minimal improvement, consider orthopedic consult

Week 10-12 final evaluation: 

• Should see 70-80% improvement 
• If less than 40% improvement, orthopedic referral recommended

Red flags requiring immediate orthopedic referral: 

• Progressive weakness (gets worse during treatment) 
• New bowel/bladder symptoms 
• Severe pain unrelieved by any position

Most insurance requires documented conservative care (8-12 weeks) before approving surgery anyway.

Do orthopedic doctors recommend chiropractors?

Yes, many orthopedic doctors refer patients to chiropractors, especially for:

Pre-surgical optimization: 

• Strengthen core before surgery 
• Improve mechanics 
• Better surgical outcomes

Post-surgical care: 

• Address scar tissue 
• Treat adjacent segment issues (areas above/below fusion) 
• Maintain spinal health

Conservative trial before surgery: 

• Most surgeons require failed conservative care 
• Chiropractic provides comprehensive conservative treatment

At Crist Chiropractic: We work closely with Franklin orthopedic surgeons. They refer patients to us, we refer to them. Collaborative care produces best outcomes.

However: Some orthopedists unfamiliar with modern, evidence-based chiropractic may have outdated perceptions. Choose providers open to collaboration.

What does comprehensive chiropractic care include for lower back pain?

Comprehensive chiropractic care combines multiple treatment approaches:

Spinal adjustments: 

• Restore joint motion in lumbar spine and SI joints 
• Reduce nerve irritation 
• Improve biomechanics

Spinal decompression therapy: 

• For disc herniations and sciatica 
• Creates negative pressure to relieve disc compression 
• 15-20 minute sessions, 2-3× weekly

Soft tissue therapy: 

• Myofascial release 
• Trigger point therapy 
• Instrument-assisted techniques 
• Addresses muscle tension perpetuating pain

Corrective exercises: 

• Core stabilization 
• Hip mobility and strength 
• Postural correction

Lifestyle modifications: 

• Ergonomic guidance 
• Proper lifting mechanics 
• Activity recommendations

Typical program: 18-24 visits over 8-12 weeks with home exercise compliance.

Is chiropractic better than physical therapy for lower back pain?

Chiropractic often produces better outcomes because it addresses spinal alignment and joint mechanics, not just muscles.

Chiropractic advantages: 

• Directly adjusts restricted joints (primary cause) 
• Includes spinal manipulation reducing nerve irritation 
• Specialized in spine and posture 
• Often faster improvement

PT advantages: 

• More extensive exercise equipment 
• May include additional modalities

Success rates: 

• Chiropractic: 70-80% 
• PT: 50-60%

Why chiropractic often works better: Lower back pain usually has spinal joint dysfunction component that adjustments address directly. PT exercises alone may not resolve joint restrictions.

Many “failed PT” cases improve with chiropractic because spine wasn’t adjusted.

Should I try chiropractic before considering back surgery?

Yes, in most non-emergency cases, comprehensive conservative care should always be attempted first.

Benefits of trying chiropractic first: 

• 70-80% avoid surgery entirely 
• No surgical risks or complications 
• Significantly lower cost ($1,200-2,400 vs $15,000-150,000) 
• No recovery downtime 
• Addresses root mechanical causes

When to skip chiropractic and go straight to surgery: 

• Progressive leg weakness or numbness 
• Loss of bowel/bladder control (cauda equina—emergency) 
• Severe trauma with fracture 
• Tumor or infection requiring immediate intervention

Even when surgery needed: Chiropractic before surgery improves outcomes through core strengthening and mechanical optimization.

Most orthopedic surgeons require documented conservative care before approving surgery anyway.

Can I see both a chiropractor and orthopedic doctor?

Absolutely. This is often the best approach.

Common scenarios:

(1) Chiropractic treatment + orthopedic imaging: Chiropractor treats conservatively while orthopedist provides advanced diagnostic imaging and monitors progress.

(2) Pre-surgical optimization: Chiropractic strengthens core and optimizes mechanics before surgery, improving surgical outcomes.

(3) Post-surgical rehabilitation: Chiropractic addresses scar tissue, adjacent segment issues, maintains spinal health after surgery.

(4) Second opinion: See both to get comprehensive perspective on treatment options.

Coordination is key: Share imaging, treatment notes, progress reports between providers for seamless care.

At Crist Chiropractic, we work closely with Franklin orthopedic surgeons for collaborative patient care.

What if my orthopedic recommends surgery but I want to try chiropractic?

You have the right to seek a second opinion and try conservative care first—if no emergency symptoms exist.

Consider:

Timeline matters: 

• Elective surgery (chronic pain, no neurological issues): Safe to try chiropractic 8-12 weeks 
• Progressive weakness or severe neurological symptoms: Don’t delay surgery

Questions to ask your orthopedist: 

• Is this surgery urgent or elective? 
• What happens if I wait 8-12 weeks? 
• Have I tried comprehensive conservative care including chiropractic? 
• What’s the success rate for this surgery?

Most surgeons respect informed patients wanting conservative options first. If they pressure you without allowing conservative trial, seek second opinion.

At Crist Chiropractic: We review your imaging, provide honest assessment of whether chiropractic can help, and expected timeline. If surgery truly necessary, we tell you.

When is surgery actually necessary for lower back pain?

Surgery is necessary when conservative care fails or serious conditions exist:

Absolute surgical indications (urgent/emergency): 

• Cauda equina syndrome (loss of bowel/bladder control) 
• Progressive severe weakness indicating nerve damage • Spinal cord compression 
• Fractures with instability 
• Spinal tumors or infections

Relative surgical indications (elective after failed conservative care): 

• Severe disc herniation with intractable pain (12+ weeks conservative care failed) 
• Severe spinal stenosis limiting walking/function 
• Unstable spondylolisthesis 
• Significant structural deformity

Timeline: Most non-emergency surgery requires minimum 6-12 weeks documented conservative care first.

Success rates: 80-90% initially, but 10-20% develop complications. 60-70% satisfied long-term (5-10 years).

Bottom line: Surgery should be last resort after comprehensive conservative care fails—except in emergencies.

Ready for an honest assessment of whether you need a chiropractor, orthopedic doctor, or both? Get expert evaluation with no pressure—just clear guidance for your specific situation.

📞 (615) 771-0022
🌐 Book OnlineCrist Chiropractic | Franklin, Cool Springs & Brentwood, TN
Tennessee Chiropractor of the Year | 25+ Years Treating Lower Back Pain
Working Collaboratively with Franklin Orthopedic Surgeons
⭐ 500+ five-star reviews